This is a post from the blog of Rod Begbie, who is one…
                       XXXX

“Groovy Motherfucker”

Unsolicitated Untestimonial

June 2, 2004

Unsolicitated Untestimonial

When I moved to America six years ago, I opened a bank account with BankBoston. This decision was made based upon a wide variety of important criteria, the main ones being “Which bank is the first one I find when I search the web for Bank and Boston?” and “Which bank has a branch closest to work?”

They were swallowed up by Fleet a few years back, which is now in the process of being swallowed by Bank of America.

Over time, I’ve had a pretty good relationship with them. Their online and phone banking facilities have generally been excellent, and on the odd occassion that I’ve been hit by fees, it’s usually been my own fault. (And on the times that it wasn’t, their CSRs have made a decent effort to pay me back.)

But during our recent house-buying, I got hit in the groin by a shitty business decision of Fleet’s. I had an old checking account which has a $2000 overdraft. I was planning on using this overdraft to contribute towards our closing costs. However, since the account had been dormant for 6 months, and without any prior warning, Fleet closed the account. 4 days before we closed on the house.

I spent a good couple of hours on the phone with a CSR that night. No, there was no way they could resuscitate the account. No, there was no way they could create a new overdraft on our joint account in the next two days. It was all the computer. The computer rules over all. The computer closes accounts whenever it feels like it, and there is no way to stop it. In fact, since the account had had a zero balance for 6 months, the computer should have closed it 6 months ago. I should be grateful that it hadn’t been closed already.

Needless to say, I swore that I was leaving Fleet A.S.A.P. (But leaving a penny in each account so that the computer wouldn’t close them, which I’d transfer between the accounts every so often so they’d have to incur the cost of mailing me statements.)

So we opened accounts with Citizens Bank, who are the second largest bank in these parts. I was wary, because they’re owned by the Royal Bank of Scotland, who dicked me over severely when I was a student (and they were the only bank on campus), but I figured they were worth a shot.

Dear Lord, it makes me see that I’ve been lucky to have been with Fleet all these years!

In the course of one short month, they’ve sent us two boxes of checks (identically numbered, but one set has only my name on them, while the other has Joy’s and mine), accidentally changed our house number on their records (so mail mysteriously changed from going to 5 Berkeley St to 4 Berkeley St), and although Joy’s ATM card arrived over a week ago, I had to phone and request mine which still hasn’t arrived, making the account pretty much useless to me.

In addition, their customer phone system is pathetic. They ask you to punch in your Account Number, not your ATM card number (something you’re more likely to have on you). They ask you to punch in your SSN. And then, when you get to a human being, they ask you for all the information again.

So the question remains: Do I swallow my principals and stick it out with Fleet, for despite them being subjects to The Computer, they at least have an ounce of competance? Do I stay with Citizens, and hope they get better? Or do I go off searching again?

Comments

About 7 years, 8 months ago, Camilo commented:

Form whatvyou tell, it is better to stick to the Fleet. BoA is still good, even though it blames the all powerful computer.

Because, really, giving your SSN to the CSR at Citizen is scary. And now all your readers know where you live!!

About 7 years, 8 months ago, David commented:

As much as I regret banking with Fleet, I prefer them tenfold to Citizens, who gobbled up my bank (US Trust) a few years back and stripped every single customer-friendly policy. They instituted fees for EVERYTHING. Their customer support was terrible, unless you had one of their "elite" accounts that had its own CSRs, people who I assume got some basic job training that the others lacked. At least with Fleet, I've been able to talk to a person to find out what's gone wrong when it's gone wrong (though they've yet, in my experience, to suggest that their computers had discretion over my finances). Also, it seems that Fleet is overt in their cheating of consumers, while Citizens is covert. I guess I'd rather be mugged by Fleet than pickpocketed by Citizens.

About 7 years, 8 months ago, Dad commented:

Think yourself lucky that you are not still with Bank of Scotland that was taken over by Halifax to become HBOS (should more appropriately be labelled BOSH) and whose Internet banking Service has only a small fraction of the functionality that the old HOBS system, introduced in 1985, had.

Best banks in UK now are the ones that used to be Building Societies. We use both Abbey and Northern Rock for important banking and BOSH for day to day trivia.

About 7 years, 8 months ago, Matthew commented:

I hate both banks. I had an account with Fleet some 7-8 years ago, and I left abruptly when suddenly my monthly fees jumped from a dollar or two up to in excess of $15.

I've had an account with the Lowell Five ever since. Most of my friends go with smaller banks as well.

About 7 years, 8 months ago, TC commented:

Oh sweet holy Jesus, Rod. Leave Citizens before they screw you again. We just moved to Salem Five; don't think they have good coverage in Somerville (they just opened a branch in Malden which is why we went there), but I also have a small account at Wainwright Bank which I like and which has fairly progressive politics mixed in with their business philosophy. Wainwright is in Davis Sq., and up by Alewife station, and in Kendall- basically blanketing downtown Boston & Cambridge.

But Citizens... run. Run away.

About 7 years, 8 months ago, Ram commented:

I would urge everyone to switch over to a Credit Union. I personally use Digital Federal Credit Union <dcu.org> and have been a happy customer since 5 years. They offer free checking + checks (with direct deposit of your pay), $5 minimum balance in savings (which is actually a share), free online banking + Bill Payment + Yodlee, Access to any SUM ATM and 5 refunds / month on foreign (non SUM) ATM charges.

Post a comment

Due to spam, posting comments to old entries is disabled.

saute-swinish